![Hobo Mama wants you to know she's a professional blogger! Look at how professional she's being! Hobo Mama wants you to know she's a professional blogger! Look at how professional she's being!](http://images.hobomama.com/hm-disclosure-short.png)
I'm reprinting this from Hobo Mama in the hopes that children's authors take note: We need more variety in our characters, on so many levels. One is in animal-gender form.
All cats are girls, and all other animals are boys.
You'd think this was biologically improbable, but it's true.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEi2r7alUTF5lkMOR4Txakh40eyNHC1G1ZjlZnYE2GRr8aDY2OKg-mX_TWMwUxBfO4dwRLVyqYprKCP0dDCH5ukmbLIOJ8CSRTPECJghsxKClbUcGfdLtcHBMHe6zfIHh_9vuq_KKZI8ewhh/s640/pets-tails-cover.jpg)
"I love my budgie — his tail is a beautiful blue."
"I love my stick insect — his tail is like a twig."
"I love my fish — his tail goes swish-swish."
I commend Wilkinson on her extensive research that correctly identified the masculinity of nearly all pets.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjakD7zak7LaFVX_717rfBQMTM1TGU3mc_y2KISLoogMTnXtFduyECTtEszfW-E_kdEA9VkhYfl5znFwfoZQkJ1XrSce1afeLMwMcH14lQqPS1E4BsuZKijfWqdcj7qkhgcks8UOSnahnyp/s640/pets-tales-page.jpg)
And then, suddenly, on the last page, for the final animal:
"I love my kitten — her tail is fluffy."
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjFeNnhli6paZu_cDcL1KTy-M4GdPNLgiB4m_qLu-FkqtOMTBO2-IwnibUjJitR_BuDX9bbyjEg5RIisgD9RCt24wnMQBPUEVvEcQrhYq6B2TTMuM2bxpPjzDxqTbdvAI4XyTVRcNyiG5n_/s640/pets-tails-cat.jpg)
"HER tail"!
That's seven boy animals to one girl. Though, honestly, considering that only cats are female, statistically speaking it's a miracle a girl slipped in at all!
Ok, I kid, but this happens so often in children's literature and other media that it's a trope. Cats are girls, dogs are boys … and so is everything else. That's why it seems jarring for people that the dinosaurs in Jurassic Park/World are females. Dinosaurs for sure were all boys, weren't they?
When I read this book out loud to my kids, I try to vary the genders a little to do my part.
I also have long rejoiced in the tales of Bunnicula, with their sarcastic male cat protagonist.
How often have you seen this cats-are-girls convention vs. otherwise?
P.S. Our two cats are girls. Because that's all there is. Or so I've been told.
Why are you dressing me in a skirt? I defy your gender stereotypes! |
0 comments:
Post a Comment